Aphantastic Artist: When Your Mind's Eye is Blind

"Just picture it in your mind's eye."

If you have aphantasia, you've probably heard this phrase countless times from art teachers, YouTube tutorials, and well-meaning friends. And if you're like me, you've probably thought, "What mind's eye?"

Aphantasia—the inability to form mental images—affects an estimated 2-5% of the population. For those of us who experience it, the world of visual art can feel like we're trying to paint a sunset we've never seen, sculpt a face we can't visualize, or design something that exists only in the imaginations we don't have.

But here's the thing: some of the most successful artists throughout history likely had aphantasia. And today, artists with aphantasia are creating stunning work that rivals anything produced by their visualizing counterparts.

Before we dive in, here’s my shameless plug: I created something just for us. The Prompt & Palette: Aphantastic Art Journal is now available on Amazon. (Get 12 free prompts from the collection here!) It’s designed with aphantasia in mind — no “visualize it first” instructions, just simple, concrete prompts that anyone can respond to. If you’ve ever opened an art journal and thought, “what mind’s eye?” this flips the script and gives you a place to start.

The Unique Challenges We Face

The Reference Problem

Most art instruction assumes you can see things in your mind. "Imagine the light hitting the sphere," they say. "Visualize how the fabric would drape." When your mind's eye is a blank screen, these instructions feel like being asked to describe a movie you've never watched.

Memory and Observation

Without the ability to replay visual memories, drawing from life or memory becomes exponentially harder. That beautiful sunset you saw last week? Gone, except for whatever emotional impression it left and maybe some factual details you consciously noted.

Creative Visualization

The ideation phase—that magical moment when artists "see" their finished piece before creating it—can feel impossible. How do you plan a composition when you can't preview it in your mind?

The Aphantasic Artist's Toolkit: Strategies That Actually Work

1. Become a Reference Hoarder

Since we can't rely on mental imagery, we need external visual libraries. Build massive collections of:

• Photos organized by subject, lighting, pose, etc.

• Screenshots of color palettes that work well together

• Examples of compositions you admire

• Texture references for different materials

Use tools like Pinterest, PureRef, or even simple folders on your computer. The key is organization—you need to find things quickly when inspiration strikes.

2. Master the Art of Breaking Things Down

Instead of trying to visualize a complete image, focus on individual elements:

• Study how light behaves on different surfaces

• Learn the anatomy of shadows separately from the objects that cast them

• Practice drawing individual features before attempting full portraits

• Understand color theory as a set of rules rather than intuitive choices

3. Embrace External Sketching

Your sketchbook becomes your visual thinking space. Use it to:

• Work out compositions through thumbnail sketches

• Test color combinations with quick swatches

• Document your process so you can repeat successful techniques

• Keep visual notes about techniques that work for you

4. Develop Your Analytical Eye

We may not be able to visualize, but we can become exceptionally good at seeing and analyzing what's in front of us. Practice:

• Really looking at your subject matter—shapes, proportions, relationships

• Breaking complex forms into simple geometric shapes

• Identifying patterns in successful artworks

• Understanding why certain compositions work better than others

5. Use Technology as Your Visual Brain

Digital tools can supplement what our minds can't do:

• Use 3D software to visualize lighting and composition

• Try augmented reality apps that let you "place" your art in spaces

• Use color picker tools to analyze successful color schemes

• Leverage AI image generators for initial concept exploration

The Hidden Advantages

Having aphantasia isn't just a limitation to overcome—it comes with genuine advantages:

Less Attachment to Preconceived Ideas: We're often more flexible about changing our work because we're not attached to a specific mental image.

Better Observational Skills: We tend to develop exceptional ability to see what's actually there rather than what we think should be there.

Technical Precision: Without the distraction of mental imagery, we often become more focused on technique and process.

Unique Perspective: Our work often has a distinctive quality because we approach creation differently than visualizing artists.

Working With Your Brain, Not Against It

The key to success as an aphantasic artist is accepting that your creative process will look different—and that's okay. You might:

• Work more systematically than other artists

• Rely more heavily on technical knowledge

• Need more time for planning and reference gathering

• Find certain styles or subjects more natural to you than others

Finding Your Artistic Voice

Some of the most successful aphantasic artists work in:

• Abstract art: Where visualization is less critical than understanding color, form, and composition

• Technical illustration: Where accuracy and systematic approach are valued

• Digital art: Where you can iterate quickly and build visual libraries

• Sculpture: Where you can feel your way through the process

• Photography: Where you're capturing rather than creating imagery

The Bottom Line

Aphantasia doesn't make you less creative or less capable as an artist—it just means you need different tools and strategies. Once you stop trying to work like a visualizing artist and start working like an aphantasic artist, you might be surprised by what you can create.

Your blank mind's eye isn't a creative deficit; it's just a different starting point. And sometimes, starting from nothing means you have more freedom to create something entirely new.

What strategies have worked for you as an aphantasic artist? Share your experiences in the comments below.

Follow along on Instagram, TikTok, and LinkedIn for visuals and bite-sized insights from this piece. And if this resonated, share it with someone else who gets it.

Sign up here to receive our newsletter and stay connected!

About the Author
Gal is an autistic artist, late-diagnosed at 49, and the creator of AuRTistic Expressions—a space where neurodivergent truth meets creative survival. Through blog posts, printables, courses, and the “This Might Get Messy” podcast, Gal explores what it means to unmask safely, communicate authentically, and make art that doesn’t ask for permission. Stick around—there’s plenty more where this came from.

AI generated bio